Maybe I’m Old School

I’ve always been a bit nerdy about history, especially American history. Growing up, I thought about the Founding Fathers, Abraham Lincoln, and American presidents the way other kids thought about superheroes or outer space. One Halloween, I went all in and dressed up as Benjamin Franklin. I had the bifocals, an itchy wig, and a mini copy of the Declaration of Independence that I refused to put down.

For a while, I even told my parents I wanted to be a printer when I grew up, like Franklin. Childhood me thought running a printing press was a perfectly reasonable career to aim for in the 21st century. (It is not, and I am still crestfallen by this news.)

Photographic evidence of my Benjamin Franklin obsession come to life.

I never really lost that love for American history, and with our nation’s 250th anniversary here, I hope you’ll indulge me for a few minutes.

I still get something in my chest when I read certain speeches from American history. Lately, though, I’ve felt a little self-conscious admitting it. Because somewhere along the way, it became unfashionable to talk about America like it was headed toward something better. Talking that way can sound like you’re overlooking everything wrong with America. Say you believe America can work for everyone, regardless of race, whom they love, or how they vote, and you risk sounding hopelessly naive.

I understand the skepticism. I have plenty of my own. But I don’t want to give up on that belief, and some of the people I grew up reading about give me reasons to hold on to it.

Benjamin Franklin, a spirit of compromise

“When you assemble a number of men to have the advantage of their joint wisdom, you inevitably assemble with those men, all their prejudices, their passions, their errors of opinion, their local interests, and their selfish views. From such an assembly can a perfect production be expected?”

- Benjamin Franklin, Closing Speech at the Constitutional Convention, September 17, 1787

(You saw the Halloween costume. I had to start with Franklin.)

It was September 17, 1787, the final day of the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. Franklin was 81 and too frail to stand, so his remarks were read aloud by James Wilson of Pennsylvania shortly before the delegates were asked to sign the final draft of the Constitution. He openly acknowledged that he was not leaving the convention perfectly satisfied with the document before him.

“I confess that there are several parts of this constitution which I do not at present approve,” he said, “but I am not sure I shall never approve them.”

The last part is what I love. He had objections, but he allowed for the possibility he was wrong. “The older I grow, the more apt I am to doubt my own judgement, and to pay respect to the judgement of others.”

He asked other delegates to consider doing the same. They had spent months arguing. None had gotten everything they wanted. Franklin thought they should sign anyway.

There are limits to compromise, of course, and some of the compromises made in that room would have terrible consequences. But the willingness to reconsider your own judgement is a habit I wish we valued more. I would like to see more of it in our politics, and I know I could use more of it myself.

Later that day, James Madison wrote down that Franklin looked at the sun painted on the back of Washington’s chair and said he had spent the whole convention wondering whether it was a rising or setting sun. “But now at length I have the happiness to know that it is a rising and not a setting Sun.” Franklin never mistook the Constitution for a perfect or permanent answer. What mattered to him was building a system sturdy enough to endure and humble enough to improve.

I think a nation founded on the belief that it can improve itself is something close to a miracle, and I hope we don’t become too cynical to appreciate it.

Abraham Lincoln, a spirit of grace

“Fondly do we hope, fervently do we pray, that this mighty scourge of war may speedily pass away. Yet, if God wills that it continue until all the wealth piled by the bondsman’s two hundred and fifty years of unrequited toil shall be sunk and until every drop of blood drawn with the lash shall be paid by another drawn with the sword as was said three thousand years ago so still it must be said ‘the judgements of the Lord are true and righteous altogether.’”

- Abraham Lincoln, Second Inaugural Address, March 4, 1865

Lincoln’s second inaugural is a speech I keep coming back to. Lincoln had spent his first term trying to save the Union. By the spring of 1865, with Sherman marching through the South and Grant pressing Lee in Virginia, he had earned a second term - and with it, the opportunity to shape what came next.

He had every political incentive to turn his second inaugural into a victory lap - to name the traitors and promise them the reckoning they deserved. But he didn’t take that chance. He spoke about the war as a wound the whole country had earned for the sin of slavery. "Both read the same Bible, and pray to the same God; and each invokes His aid against the other.” He did not assume that victory would prove the North innocent of the nation’s wrongs.

Amidst all that grief and destruction, he called the nation toward mercy rather than judgment. To Lincoln, the men who fought against him were still his countrymen, and the work ahead was not vengeance but reconciliation. “With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in to bind up the nation’s wounds, to care for him who shall have borne the battle and for his widow and his orphan - to do all which may achieve and cherish a just and lasting peace among ourselves and with all nations.”

I think the true measure of a country is how it treats the people it has every reason not to treat kindly, and I hope that’s a standard from Lincoln we haven’t quietly abandoned.

Franklin Roosevelt, a spirit of solidarity

“Freedom means the supremacy of human rights everywhere. Our support goes to those who struggle to gain those rights or keep them. Our strength is our unity of purpose. To that high concept there can be no end save victory.”

- Franklin Delano Roosevelt, State of the Union Address, January 6, 1941

In January 1941, Franklin Roosevelt stood before a nation watching tyranny sweep across Europe. Poland had fallen. Denmark and Norway had fallen. Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, and even France had fallen. He used that moment to steady a reluctant nation for what lay ahead, and in doing so he tried to define what the struggle was really about. He named four freedoms he thought belonged to every person alive: freedom of speech and expression, freedom of worship, freedom from want, and freedom from fear. After each freedom came the same refrain: “everywhere in the world,” until no one could pretend he was speaking only about Americans.

It is the third freedom that has stuck with me. Freedom from want.

So much of our politics has become centered around what government should be prevented from doing to us. But I think Roosevelt was right to ask what freedom means to someone who cannot afford food, medical care, or a secure old age.

You can have rights on paper and still have very few choices in your daily life. Someone who is worried about losing their home or feeding their children may not feel particularly free.

I appreciate that Roosevelt put a decent shot at a stable life in the same breath as speech and worship. And I agree with him that a freedom that cannot reach the kitchen table is only a partial one, and I hope we have not taught ourselves to be indifferent to the rest.

Eleanor Roosevelt, a spirit of dignity

“No one race and no one people can claim to have done all the work to achieve greater dignity for human beings and greater freedom to develop human personality. In each generation and in each country there must be a continuation of the struggle and new steps forward must be taken since this is preeminently a field in which to stand still is to retreat.”

- Eleanor Roosevelt, Speech at the Sorbonne, Paris, September 28, 1948

FDR imagined freedoms that belonged to every person, but Eleanor Roosevelt would spend the years after his death trying to place those freedoms into the moral vocabulary of the entire world.

When the war was over and Franklin was gone, another Roosevelt stood at the Sorbonne in Paris before a continent still digging itself from the rubble. Eleanor Roosevelt had spent two years chairing the commission that wrote the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and she had come to make the case that human freedom was the defining question of the age. She understood that democracy is slow - that all its arguments, elections, and compromises can make a benevolent dictatorship seem attractive to people in a hurry - but she refused to accept that as an excuse for tyranny. “There is no way of insuring that a dictatorship will remain benevolent or that the power once in the hands of a few will be returned to the people without struggle or revolution.”

She chose the long road of democracy because the principles of freedom are precisely the things that cannot be bargained away for efficiency. And she would not let anyone treat the work as finished. No nation and no generation inherits dignity fully secured. Each must work to preserve and expand it. Standing in the aftermath of one of the worst tragedies in modern human history, Eleanor Roosevelt insisted that the answer to humanity’s failures was more dignity and freedom, not less.

I think someone who could stand amid the ruins of humanity’s darkest moment and still wager on human dignity understood something about hope that we could all stand to relearn.

Martin Luther King Jr., a spirit of hope

“It is obvious today that America has defaulted on this promissory note insofar as her citizens of color are concerned. Instead of honoring this sacred obligation, America has given the negro people a bad check, a check that has come back marked ‘insufficient funds.’ But we refuse to believe that the bank of justice is bankrupt.”

- Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom, August 28, 1963

Nearly a century after Lincoln, another giant stood in Lincoln’s shadow to say that the American promise remained unfulfilled for Black Americans.

He made the point in the language of money, arguing that America had written every citizen a check, drawn on the words of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, but when Black Americans went to cash it, the nation defaulted on its obligation.

Instead of turning a century of broken promises into bitterness, Martin Luther King turned it into a dream. He dreamed of a country that would measure his children by their character instead of their skin. He dreamed of the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slaveholders sharing one table. He was not asking America to become something entirely new. He was asking it to honor what it had promised from the very beginning

I still believe that “all men are created equal” names an obligation that belongs to all people, and I hope we never grow comfortable excluding anyone from that promise.

What I want to carry forward

I know writing a post like this can give the wrong impression. A collection of beautiful quotes can make history seem cleaner than what it was.

Franklin owned enslaved people for much of his life. FDR authorized the incarceration of Japanese Americans during World War II. Admiring their words doesn’t make those actions excusable, and the contradiction makes it more painful.

Americans didn’t need a founding document to know that slavery or racial persecution or tyranny were wrong. But our country’s stated ideals have given people a powerful way to challenge our country to advance according to the terms it was built on.

That is how I want to read these speeches and quotes. I want to learn from them without turning the people who delivered them into saints. Their words can still ask something of us, even when their lives fell short.

What stays with me is Franklin admitting he will keep his mind open. Lincoln asking a devastated country to make room for charity. FDR including economic security in his account of freedom. Eleanor Roosevelt warning that dignity has to be defended. King reminding that none of these promises mean very much if they are not extended to everyone.

I don’t agree with everything these people believed or did, but I do hope those particular ideas remain a part of how we think and talk about our country.

There are days when I find that difficult and where cynicism feels sensible, especially when we seemingly repeat the failures of the past. I understand why people lose patience, but I still want a country that works for more people than it does today. I want us to be able to say that plainly and then argue seriously about how to get there.

As we celebrate the Fourth of July and the 250th anniversary of this country, I think about Franklin at the end of that long summer in Philadelphia. He spent months staring at the sun on the back of George Washington’s chair, wondering whether it was rising or setting. Only when the Constitution was finally complete did he decide he knew the answer.

“It is a rising and not a setting Sun.”

The remarkable thing is that every person I have written about inherited that same sunrise and insisted that more people ought to stand in its light. Lincoln tried to bind up the nation’s wounds. FDR expanded the meaning of freedom itself. Eleanor Roosevelt carried human dignity to people beyond the United States. King demanded that the promises written at the founding be honored for all Americans.

None of them believed the work was finished. None of them mistook the country they had for the country they hoped to build.

Maybe I’m old school. But if believing that America can keep widening that circle of freedom, dignity, opportunity, and belonging makes me old fashioned, then I am content to wear that label.

And like Franklin, I am still betting that the sun continues to rise.

Next
Next

Who Gets to Shape the Age of AI?